Zangoose got the cookie.
That-No-Existing-User put a monkey to distract Zangoose, then takes cookie.
Zangoose throw a boomerang at That-No-Existing-User to make it dizzy then takes the boomerang and cookie.
I-Am-Me is hitting Zangoose in the head then takes cookie.
Seal4246 takes a bomb and throws at I-Am-Me then catches the cookie.
So on and on and on.. The only rule is NOBODY eats the cookie, unless if the game has been inactive for a month the one that took it the last time will eat it and we start a new game.